Well, the lone Ranger was wrong… Yes the Cooper STT sure does look the part, sort of like some caravans that copy our style. But they did not hold up. In being late on the draw, and still running my good old Standard BFG Muddies, I missed out on a big disappointment !!! The BFG Muddies hold up the best so far, now Number One for fifteen years. I guess I will stay with the good old “tried and true”…
In TIP # 118 “Perils and Positives of Mud Terrains, and a Hidden Danger”, I indicated that I was headed in the direction of the Cooper STT as they looked a lot like the Mickey Thompson Baja Claw, another tried and true famous off road race tyre that makes it across the Baja Peninsula in Mexico; that is such a tyre punisher. Well I am headed for the STTs no more. The first long term test of the Coopers came in after a large Outback crossing. At less than 20,000 kms ST’s were changed out on Warranty due to extreme chipping on gravel and rock, in favour of the STT. Now at 40,000 km it has happened again, and if you gave them to me I would not put the STTs on my tow vehicle.
It looks like the compound formulae in the rubber is wrong, again; and the gravel of roads like the Oodnadatta eats them… Badly… Not just chipping of the tread, but cracking of rock and stone puncture in between the lugs…. They might be just fine, they might still be a good serviceable tyre, but not on my Effie I can assure you. Not even if they were free.. These did not hold up on a Landcruiser, and my Effie would be running a ton heavier.
Years ago, we got bad reports from the Coopers in severe going in the Outback. This new series of ST and STT had my hopes up and I ALMOST BECAME A COOPER FAN!!! Oooooopps, not now… Well, in favour of the Coopers, in this crossing test on a Landcruiser, there was not one flat tyre. And, unlike the results of Coopers in the past, there were no incidents of sidewall staking. But in all fairness, it does not look like they will go more than 40,000- 50,000 kms in the Outback at best, and this Owner estimates only 20-25% was done on gravel tracks.. In all fairness, I had higher hopes than that. In favour: It does look like the new Sidewalls have succeeded in making a much better and stronger tyre for the Outback; I will give them that much credit. Coopers still have an attractive tread pattern, in all fairness it is attractive to severe mud work, and they have improved…. But if you go the Cooper direction, OK, just don’t have high expectations for them lasting for much mileage.. They appear now to be stronger in the sidewall, but they do not have a long live expectancy, and the quote from this unnamed Owner xxxx is “They are a disappointment”…. I agree. They are here now and after looking at them myself here is my judgment: At 40,000 kms, with only 20-25% on gravel roads, they look so bad that I would not bother to remount them if given to me for free. STTs are “out” for the lone Ranger…
My BFGs Muddies have been my choice for 15 years now… I currently have them on two Landcruisers, and have had them on two Effies, an F-350 and my current F-250, and they will remain my first choice until something better comes along…
Regards to all from the lone Ranger,
Semper Fidelis