Monday, Apr 11, 2005 at 19:06
Hello Maureen and David,
As usual I have a perspective that comes from not the once or twice of doing things, but more like the 1000 and seeing the results... Of the 30 that have come back for second vans from us, 29 have gone larger. Here is my scientific prognosis: Facts
1) Look, 18' is plenty adequate for two people...
2) 20' trends more into luxury.
3) I have owned both, and with an F-350 towing for three years, I do not believe there is any real difference in access between the two in the rough going.... I mean if it even exists it is in the less than 1% category... You may have to back and fill on the three point turn a couple of times, but to think that somehow an 18' is going more places than a 20', is a real stretch of imagination. I do not think that is a real worry.
4) The F-250 will not know the difference in general towing.
5) The risk is on the side of the 18', and will you enjoy the travel mode so much that you do it more than you think in the future.... The 18' is adequate, but may not be as enjoyable when you are in a nice place where your stationary lifestyle will be remembered.
6) They will both get there in the same time with an F-250... Towing with Toyota, time of travel would be a small consideration as you would be a bit slower, but not with an F-350.... No difference
7) Overall 20' success rates or happiness quotient have now overtaken the 18' and 20' is now the most popular size...
8) You may be annoyed by some of the shortcomings of the layouts and storage in 18'...
Final analysis summary: You should come here and sit in the 18' and the 20' for an extended period of time... There is no difference to us which one you choose, or the 19' that does almost the same job. But if you sit in them for an hour, you will know for yourself, going back and forth, which one suits you... My guess is the safe route is 19', that overcomes most of the shorcomings of the 18' layout, and will give you more counterspace and a better face to face dining area... Try it on, and see if I am right... In any case, the back and forth in and out sitting in a couple of them will answer it for you..
Insight from the "Lone Ranger" at
Bushtracker, 'lookin out for ya'
AnswerID:
566161